An analysis of the criticisms of kohlbergs moral development stages

Do parental or societal influences play a greater role in moral development? He has not just expanded on Piaget's stages of moral judgment but has done so in an inspiring way.

Kohlberg theory of moral development examples

One boy said that Heinz might steal the drug if he wanted his wife to live, but that he doesn't have to if he wants to marry someone younger and better-looking Kohlberg, , p. They see that group norms of care and empathy have little impact on the impersonal interactions of city life, and they see the need for a formal legal structure to ensure moral conduct. Realizing the limitations of the current stage of thinking is the driving force behind moral development, as each progressive stage is more adequate than the last. Kohlberg's theory represented an important contribution to the psychological study of moral reasoning and its effect on behavior, but it contains a number of flaws and problematic assumptions. Haan found that their thinking was more strongly postconventional than that of a matched sample of nonparticipants, but this f inding was not replicated for some other protests, apparently because moral principles were not at stake Keniston, , pp. Thus far, the studies have supported Kohlberg's stage sequence. Pre-conventional[ edit ] The pre-conventional level of moral reasoning is especially common in children, although adults can also exhibit this level of reasoning. The result would be chaos; society couldn't function. In addition, Kohlberg and his co-workers Colby et al. Respondents at stage 2 are still said to reason at the preconventional level because they speak as isolated individuals rather than as members of society.

Consequently, he has temporarily dropped stage 6 from his scoring manual, calling it a "theoretical stage" and scoring all postconventional responses as stage 5 Colby and Kohlberg,p.

They also begin to consider how individuals might coordinate their interests in terms of mutually beneficial deals. Carol Gilligan has argued that Kohlberg's theory is excessively androcentric.

If the druggist did this, even he would recognize that life must take priority over property; for he wouldn't want to risk finding himself in the wife's shoes with property valued over life. The principles of justice guide us toward decisions based on an equal respect for all.

kohlbergs stages of moral development real life examples

An evaluation of this question, however, must await closer reviews of the literature. Accordingly, one might expect thinking about moral issues to continue to develop throughout adolescence.

But to the extent they do go through the stages, they proceed in order. This young man went on to say that "from a moral standpoint" Heinz should save the life of even a stranger, since to be consistent, the value of a life means any life. When Kohlberg says that his stages are hierarchically integrated, he means that people do not lose the insights gained at earlier stages, but integrate them into new, broader frameworks.

Kohlbergs stages of moral development

When Kohlberg says that his stages are hierarchically integrated, he means that people do not lose the insights gained at earlier stages, but integrate them into new, broader frameworks. Kohlberg's theory represented an important contribution to the psychological study of moral reasoning and its effect on behavior, but it contains a number of flaws and problematic assumptions. What would happen if we all started breaking the laws whenever we felt we had a good reason? In Stage six universal ethical principles driven , moral reasoning is based on abstract reasoning using universal ethical principles. At stage 5 they emphasize basic rights and the democratic processes that give everyone a say, and at stage 6 they define the principles by which agreement will be most just. Kohlberg, , p. Kohlberg believes that his stages unfold in an invariant sequence. For example, there is no guarantee that a boy who is coded at stage 3 at age 13 actually passed through stages 1 and 2 in order when he was younger. The child is motivated by self-interest to do chores. Researchers find that villagers stop at stage 3, but perhaps they continue to develop moralities in directions that Kohlberg's stages fail to capture. According to Kohlberg, someone progressing to a higher stage of moral reasoning cannot skip stages. The druggist, stage 3 subjects emphasize, was "selfish," "greedy," and "only interested in himself, not another life. Good behavior means having good motives and interpersonal feelings such as love, empathy, trust, and concern for others. Doctors advice that only one drug can an save her. Analysis To analyze this situation, Kohlberg 's model for Moral Development was used

At stage 3, they emphasize being a good person, which basically means having helpful motives toward people close to one At stage 4, the concern shifts toward obeying laws to maintain society as a whole. As a general hypothesis, he proposes that moral behavior is more consistent, predictable.

Why is moral development important

Once Kohlberg had classified the various responses into stages, he wanted to know whether his classification was reliable. Postconventional Morality Stage 5. Stages 5 and 6, finally, take a more idealized look at how people might coordinate their interests. If Kohlberg is right about the hierarchic nature of his stages, we would expect that people would still be able to understand earlier stages but consider them inferior, In fact, when Rest Rest et al. The "view of persons" can be understood as the individual's grasp of the psychology of other persons; it may be pictured as a spectrum, with stage one having no view of other persons at all, and stage six being entirely socio-centric. According to Kohlberg, someone progressing to a higher stage of moral reasoning cannot skip stages. Like Werner, she is suggesting that development may proceed along more than one line. Although Kohlberg remains committed to the cognitive-conflict model of change, he has also become interested in other strategies. People who exhibit post-conventional morality view rules as useful but changeable mechanisms—ideally rules can maintain the general social order and protect human rights. As we get into discussions and debates with others, we find our views questioned and challenged and are therefore motivated to come up with new, more comprehensive positions. Werner, we remember from Chapter 4, described hierarchic integration as a process that occurs alongside differentiation, and Kohlberg believes his stages represent increasingly differentiated structures as well.

Children younger than 10 or 11 years think about moral dilemmas one way; older children consider them differently.

Rated 5/10 based on 105 review
Download
The Criticisms of Kohlberg's Moral Development Stages Essay